Shane Reactions

Mostly on (a) the Presidency and (b) Democracy and Communication

  • Archive

  • Categories

  • Subscribe

Needed: Social Investment in an Informed Society

Posted by Peter M. Shane on November 2, 2009

You could keep yourself quite busy these days reading about and attending conferences on new models for journalism.  But the current moment of journalistic ferment is actually part of a larger and more alarming story.

The United States is dramatically underinvesting in the production and circulation of knowledge.

Three headlines reveal the larger landscape:  “America Falling: Longtime Dominance in Education Erodes.”  “Libraries Struggle with Tight Budgets.”  “US Statehouse Reporting in Decline.”

On the surface, these sound like separate issues.  Our colleges, libraries, and newspapers face distinct challenges.  To some extent, their problems have different causes, and they require different solutions.

But they share a common pathology:  The United States is relying excessively on free market forces to sustain the key institutions that produce an informed, knowledgeable society.  Those forces have fallen short.  Increased social investment has not followed.

From 1980 to 2004, state support for colleges and universities shrank from 46 to 27 percent.  Tuition as a source of support rose from 13 to 18 percent.  America faces unprecedented competition in the global knowledge economy.  But we are shifting the cost of creating competitors from the greater society to the shoulders of individual students.

Libraries fare no better.  Americans visited libraries 1.4 billion times in 2005. Over two-thirds of adults have library cards.  Yet, in 2003, 2004, and 2005, U.S. communities cut library support.  Many are trimming services just as Americans are most desperate for them.

As for newspapers, individual subscribers have never paid the full freight for gathering and reporting local news.  We have relied, instead, on advertising. 

That model unraveled in the 1990s.  Major news organizations undertook debt that they cannot repay.  Internet advertising shrank their revenue streams.  Newspaper ad revenues fell nearly a third between 2000 and 2007.

Are public media likely to meet the local news shortfall?  Federal investment in public media is currently $1.35 per person.  Most local public radio stations in the U.S. have virtually no news staff at all.  At the same time, Canada invests $22.48 per capita and England spends $80.36. 

Growing up in the 1950s and 1960s, I thought the United States was Number One in more or less everything.  More important, I thought we wanted to be.

No more.  Unless America decides to invest collectively in developing an informed, knowledgeable society, our decline is both frightening and inevitable.  “New models” for journalism, education, or the sharing of knowledge generally will fall short unless we take a hard look at our public policies on information.

2 Responses to “Needed: Social Investment in an Informed Society”

  1. Rick said

    Peter– thanks for connecting the dots. I don’t know whether you saw this in the WPost, but it’s a shrewd and interesting move in the conversation:

    “Given the precarious condition of state finances, we propose that President Obama emulate President Lincoln by creating a 21st-century version of the Morrill Act.

    Specifically, the federal government should create a hybrid model in which a limited number of our great public research and teaching universities receive basic operating support from the federal government and their respective state governments. Washington might initially choose a representative set of schools, perhaps based on their research achievements, their success in graduating students, commitment to public service and their record in having a student body that is broadly representative of society.

    Washington would provide sufficient additional funding for operations and student support to ensure broad access and continued excellence at these universities. A portion of these resources would ensure that out-of-state and in-state students pay the same tuition and have access to the same financial aid packages. The combined federal-state funding must be sufficient for these universities to maintain their preeminence as well as charge moderate fees to all U.S. citizens and permanent residents. ”

  2. And should we be considering a BBC for the USA?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: